|
J a n u a r y 2 0 0 3
|
||||||||
|
Looking into the Crystal Ball
�Every trend goes forward forever
until it ends!�
� John Neff
�All we can ever do is look at the
past to predict the future, but life is dynamic and constantly changing,
so the assumptions governing predictions are bound to be wrong.� � Leon
Levy
If predicting the future was as
positively related to the past as some may have you think, then predicting
the events of Tuesday should be as easy as knowing the events of Monday.
We don�t know about you but if most of our Tuesdays, or for that
matter any other day of the week, were like Mondays we are not sure life
would be quite as optimistic!
Over the holidays we watched a
symphony orchestra with great awe. The sixty+ members with a wide
variety of instruments produced some of the most melodic and inspiring
music we have heard. We were amazed at the timing and placement of
so many different musicians that created one beautiful piece of music.
The investment process can be like a
symphony in its intricacy, complexity and inspiring value. When you
think of all the variables that can affect one stock or investment, e.g.
management, unions, competitors, regulators, commodities, distribution
channels, advertisers, accounting, tax laws, economic conditions (local,
regional, national, global), etc. it is amazing analysis is even possible.
It is even more amazing when all the cosmic tumblers of the world
click into place and the majority of these factors align themselves in the
most favorable way possible. And, it is most unbelievable when only
one or two of these factors can undermine a perfectly good business plan
and investment.
The investment decision-making process
requires a great many skill sets that must be coordinated to create one
beautiful plan for making your money grow. In some ways it requires
the resourcefulness and intuition of a jazz musician who must be able to
improvise with the changing conditions. In other ways it requires
the discipline and patience of an orchestral member who may only provide a
few notes within a twenty- minute arrangement. Creativity and
discipline, art and science, precision and intuition, though distinctly
different, are inseparable in a good investor and their plan.
Why all the flowery analogies and what
is the point? The point is that in the 90�s we went through a period
of time where making money appeared easy. Though few people actually
earned and kept significant returns on their investments, the perception
was that it was easy nonetheless. Investing well is not easy.
And in our opinion, not only will the perception that investing is
easy diminish, the nuts and bolts of making money is going to be more
difficult. It is going to require more creativity, more research
will be required to find fewer opportunities and dispassion and discipline
will be needed in their highest forms.
Many people are experiencing
investor�s fatigue. That is the current trend in the markets is
lasting longer and is more emotionally fatiguing than they are built to
withstand. One of the difficulties with investing is how long it
sometimes takes for investment ideas to prosper.
It is ironic that an individual can devote years or a lifetime of achievement to building
a career or a business and yet grow tired of an investment or investment or plan within days,
weeks or months.
The average holding period for a stock
by a retail investor is less than one year. The average mutual fund
is held less than 2 � years. The illusion
of liquidity that the markets offer may actually be a great disservice to
the average investor. The instant
gratification world we live is fostered in part by the internet.
Many investors assume they are one �click� away from wealth.
Wealth is not created by trading.
Wealth is created and preserved by building investment plans
and portfolios.
This investor fatigue can additionally
be explained in great part by investor�s most recent experiential factors.
For example:
* 30 Bull Markets have occurred in the
past century.
* 7 Bull Markets have lasted more than
1000 days.
* 3 of those 7 have been in the last
17 years.
* Until the current Bear Market
(second longest in history), the Bear Markets of the last 17 years were
some of the shortest on record (e.g. 90-120 days).
That all adds up to a lot of good and
not much bad for a long period of time. That leads to
over-confidence and unrealistic expectations.
What trends and opportunities do we
think will unfold in the coming decade? Why should an investor
remain committed to our investment plans?
* US demographics are highlighted with
an aging population and a higher savings rate. This is a long-term
trend that will slow consumption and capital investment and normalize
corporate profits and equity returns in the foreseeable future.
* High levels of corporate and
personal debt will limit GDP growth and capital investment contributing to
normalize corporate profits and equity returns.
* We purported in a previous
newsletter that large cap domestic equity classes would experience below
average returns for the foreseeable future and we still believe this to be
true; 6-8% annualized returns.
* Small Stocks will enter a period of
out-performance relative to Large Stocks. Contributing factors will
include a regression to the mean of the cyclical underperformance; the
flexibility and additional leverage potential of smaller companies and the
investor preference for accounting and financial transparency made easier
in small company balance sheets and income statements.
* The US dollar has entered a secular
phase of easing against foreign currencies. Foreign investment in
the US, which has more than doubled since 1995, will be reduced in part by
this dollar-easing trend.
* On a large scale, China, India and
Russia will experience the fastest GDP growth rates in the world.
China is currently the 6th largest GDP in the
world. It is predicted to be the 3rd largest in five
years and could become the world�s largest in a decade. Global
capital flows will seek out business and profit potential in these areas.
* In 1970 the US represented 66% of
the globe�s market capitalization. In 2000 the US represented only
51% of the world�s market cap. Of the 500 largest companies in the
world 59% are non-US companies. Higher growth rates, more investment
opportunities an a cyclical reversion to the mean will lead to foreign
stock market out-performance in the coming decade.
* Due to the rapid economic growth,
infancy of business skill and regulation, and the non-democratic political
structures, emerging markets will be volatile. It will be imperative
to employ managers with vast experience to navigate these opportunities in
a proper risk/reward fashion.
* Interest rates will enter a secular
move to higher rates. In the short run, i.e. 2003, rates will remain
near current lows. But when the prevailing rhetoric is worries of
inflation the Fed will begin tightening. We do not expect it to
resemble the hyper inflationary environment of the 1970�s.
* Commodities have been in a long-term
underperformance period. Renewed inflationary growth and increasing
global demand for materials to build economic infrastructures will create
a secular move of out-performance. This in turn will put further
pressure on higher interest rates.
How do these trends lend themselves to
our current investment policy and asset selection?
* Due to our reduced expectations for
Large Cap performance, we are over-weighting experienced value/blend
managers who focus on buying undervalued companies. Capital Guardian
Trust, Clipper, Dodge & Cox, Tweedy Browne, Longleaf Partners, Harris
Associates, Davis, Marsico, etc. all incorporate thorough fundamental
research, long-term investment themes and risk-adjusted performance in
their management and care of your assets.
* Regarding Small Stock allocations,
we currently are allocating approximately 25% of equity portfolios to
Small Stocks when you combine Small/Mid Cap allocations. Small
stocks often have fewer analysts following their stories. It is a
more eclectic and inefficient market when it comes to analysis. It
is a more intimate environment since management is smaller and key
officers or employees can provide substantial leverage to the business.
Intuition plays a great role in small stock analysis. Our
recommended managers in this area, Baron, Wasatch Advisers and Royce
Associates, have average manager tenure of over 20 years managing small
company investments.
* Regarding International Stocks, we
have approximately 30% of an equity portfolio allocated to this asset
class. There is a blend of Large Cap Core (20%), Small Cap (6%) and
Emerging Markets (3%). Capital Guardian Trust, Longleaf, Tweedy
Browne, Harris, Putnam, Brandes and Templeton have extensive experience
managing foreign investments. Several of the organizations have
managed foreign stocks for over 30 years.
* Regarding Fixed Income, due to our
belief that interest rates are at the bottom of a long-term trend, we
remain committed to managing 5-6 year bond ladders. The improved
liquidity in these short-term ladders will protect the total return of the
bond portfolios and limit reinvestment risk. Where applicable we
have approximately 15% of the fixed income portfolio in High Yield
Securities. With an improving economy and the risk perception in
credit markets being reduced, these securities may enjoy a period of above
average performance.
There are over 10,000 mutual funds and
over 20,000 equity securities available to the investing public and
institutions. Add in to this mix insurance company investment
products, commodities, hedge funds, etc. and the investing landscape can
be overwhelming. We have spent 20 years narrowing our investment
recommendations to approximately 35 funds and 20 management firms.
In a recent interview Jack Welch, the
retired Chairman of General Electric, was asked what one piece of advice
he would give to the future business leaders of tomorrow. His answer
was he would develop in them the ability to analyze the unintended consequences of
their decisions and actions. Though confident about the choices and
plans we have implemented for our investors, our experience has humbled
us, and taught us to expect, and attempt to anticipate the unintended
consequences. What we know for sure is, �We don�t know what we don�t
know.� However, we do believe our research and discipline are
properly positioned for providing prudent and profitable long-term wealth
building. |
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
The opinions expressed in this report
are those of the author and are not necessarily the same as Howe Barnes
Investments or its research department. The contents of this letter
have been compiled from original and published sources believed to be
reliable, but are not guaranteed as to accuracy or completeness.
Howe Barnes and/or its affiliates may have an interest in, or from
time to time trade or make markets in, the securities of issues discussed
herein.
Member of New York Stock Exchange
Member Securities Investor Protection
Corporation
|
||||||||